lint sub-command

Goal is to provide a lint sub-command to check syntax of modulefiles.


  • tcl_linter configuration option defines linter program to use and its options

    • nagelfar.tcl is the default

    • --with-tcl-linter and --with-tcl-linter-opts installation options help to change this default at installation time

    • When changed with config sub-command, MODULES_LINTER environment variable is set

  • Tcl linter program defined is checked for existence by configure script

    • Use fully qualified path resolved if found

    • Print a warning message if not found

    • No error if not found as lint is not the central use case

      • Could be configured or installed after Modules installation

  • --enable-nagelfar-addons installation option defines if Nagelfar-specific syntax databases and plugins to lint modulefiles have to be installed.

    • Specific syntax databases and plugins to lint modulefiles, modulerc and global/user rc are not enabled if this option is disabled

  • --nagelfardatadir installation option defines where to install Nagelfar-specific files to lint modulefiles.

Sub-command properties

General properties:

  • Shortcut name: none

  • Accepted option: --all, --icase

  • Expected number of argument: 0 to N

  • Accept boolean variant specification: no

  • Parse module version specification: yes

  • Fully read modulefile when checking validity: no

  • Sub-command only called from top level: yes

Sub-command acts similarly than edit sub-command:

  • Resolves each specification passed as argument to a single modulefile

  • Modulefile could be specified with icase, extended_default and advanced_version_spec features

    • But no boolean specification, as we are looking for modulefiles, not a module variant

  • Call an external command over the resolved modulefiles

In case no argument is provided, it means to select everything:

  • Every global and user rc file

  • Every .modulerc and .version files in enabled modulepaths

  • Every available modulefiles in enabled modulepaths

  • Include modules declared forbidden

  • If --all option set also select all hidden modulefiles in enabled modulepaths

Arguments could also be a file path:

  • need to distinguish if it is a global/user rc file, a modulerc or a modulefile to accurately lint designated file

  • file is considered a global/user rc file if file path corresponds to user or global rc file location

  • file is considered a modulerc if filename equals .version or .modulerc

  • otherwise file is considered a modulefile

Processing is aborted as soon as one lint command execution fails

Nagelfar linting

  • Analyze full content of designated files

  • It does not evaluate files sourced by designated files

  • If --enable-nagelfar-addons is enabled (default) a specific syntax database and plugin is added to the Nagelfar command line to lint specified file depending on its type (global/user rc, modulerc or modulefile)

    • Modulefile command, their options and syntaxes are checked based on this file type

    • Since not the same command set can be used in global/user rc file, in modulerc and modulefile

Report output

  • New message block: Linting <modulefile>

  • All messages produced by Nagelfar reported under modulefile message block

  • Parse Nagelfar messages to report in a structured way:

    • <SEVERITY> line <line_number>: message

    • Message is output as a block in case it consists of several lines

    • All message prefix (prior :) is highlighted based on severity

    • Nagelfar severities mapped to Modules severities:

      • W = WARNING (sgrkey: wa)

      • E = ERROR (sgrkey: er)

      • N = NOTICE (sgrkey: in)

  • Output and verbosity levels:

    • By default, do not output message block if no message to report for modulefile

    • If verbose mode set, report empty block if no linting message

    • If silent mode set, report nothing, exit code helps to know if linter has reported error